The Brand Promise: Why Brands Succeed Or Fail

By ‘Lolu Akinwunmi

CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE: THE TRUE TEST OF EVERY BRAND PROMISE

One of the greatest misconceptions in business is that marketing alone builds brands. It is not true. Marketing may introduce a brand, create awareness, stimulate interest and persuade consumers to make that first purchase. But the real test of every brand begins only after the customer says, “Yes”. That is where customer experience takes over. Simply put, marketing makes the promise. Customer experience proves whether the promise was true.

This distinction is often overlooked by organisations that invest heavily in advertising while paying far less attention to the quality of the experience they deliver. They assume that because their campaigns are creative, their brand is strong. Again, nothing could be further from the truth. A brilliant advertisement may persuade someone to try a product once. Only a memorable customer experience persuades them to buy it again. In other words, marketing may win customers; customer experience keeps them.

Consider a luxury hotel that advertises exceptional hospitality, personalised service and world-class comfort. If guests arrive to find indifferent staff, poorly maintained rooms and slow service, the advertising has not strengthened the brand. It has damaged it. Why? Because the experience contradicted the promise.

The same applies to virtually every sector. A bank may position itself as offering prompt service and customer-friendly, but if customers spend hours resolving simple issues, frustration quickly replaces confidence.

An airline may promise punctuality and convenience, but repeated delays and poor communication gradually erode trust.

An online retailer may advertise next-day delivery, but if orders consistently arrive late, customers begin to question everything else the company says.

The lesson is simple. Customers remember experiences far longer than advertisements. This explains why customer experience has become one of the most important sources of competitive advantage in today’s marketplace. Products can often be copied. Prices can be matched. Technology can be acquired. Even advertising ideas are frequently imitated. Outstanding customer experiences, however, are much harder to replicate because they depend on organisational culture, leadership, employee behaviour and operational excellence.

That is why some organisations enjoy extraordinary customer loyalty despite spending relatively modest amounts on advertising. They consistently deliver experiences that customers value.

One of the greatest responsibilities of marketing communication professionals is therefore to avoid making promises the organisation is not equipped to fulfil. Marketing should never operate in isolation from operations. Before launching a campaign, marketers should ask several important questions:

Can our customer service teams deliver this promise?
Can our operational systems support these expectations?
Can our employees consistently provide the experience we are advertising?
Can we sustain this standard over time?
If the answer to these questions is uncertain, then perhaps the communication should be reconsidered.

There is an old saying that advertising can accelerate success; but it can also accelerate failure. A poor product with limited publicity disappoints relatively few people. A poor product supported by a brilliant advertising campaign disappoints many more. The larger the promise, the greater the disappointment when reality falls short. This is why customer experience should never be viewed as the responsibility of one department:

Every employee contributes to it.
The receptionist welcoming visitors.
The call centre agent handling enquiries.
The salesperson explaining product features.
The technician resolving technical issues.
The delivery driver arriving on schedule.
The accountant processing refunds.
The chief executive shaping organisational culture.
Each interaction becomes part of the customer’s overall perception of the brand. In reality, customers do not separate marketing from operations. To them, there is only one brand. Every interaction either strengthens or weakens it. Perhaps this explains why some of the world’s most admired organisations place enormous emphasis on customer experience.

Amazon built its reputation not simply through advertising, but by relentlessly simplifying shopping, improving delivery and making returns remarkably easy.

Apple stores were designed not merely to sell products, but to create experiences that reflected the company’s promise of simplicity, innovation and elegance.

Closer to home, organisations that consistently delight customers understand that every interaction is an opportunity either to reinforce trust or diminish it. The experience itself becomes the marketing.

Ultimately, the strongest brands are built not by the advertisements customers remember, but by the experiences they never forget. This is where brands truly succeed or fail: Marketing opens the door; Customer experience determines whether customers ever return.

Next in MSS-09.05: What Happens When A Brand Breaks Its Promises?

Please feel free to comment, share and invite others to subscribe to The MarCom Strategic Series (MSS). Thank you.

‘Lolu Akinwunmi
Publisher, The MarCom Strategic Series (MSS)